MarioWiki:Proposals

Proposals can be new features (such as an extension), removal of a previously added feature that has tired out, or new policies that must be approved via consensus before any action(s) are done. Any user can support or oppose, but must have a strong reason for doing so, not, e.g., "I like this idea!" "Vote" periods last for one week. All past proposals are archived. A proposal section works like a discussion page: comments are brought up and replied to using indents (colons, such as : or ::::) and all edits are signed using the code {{user|User name}}. Signing with the signature code ~~~(~) is not allowed due to technical issues. How To Actions that users feel are appropriate to have community approval first can be added by anyone, but they must have a strong argument. Users then vote and discuss on the issue during that week. The "deadline" for the proposal is one week from posting at: Monday to Thursday: 17:00 (5pm) Friday and Saturday: 20:00 (8pm) Sunday: 15:00 (3pm) Every vote should have a reason accompanying it. At any time a vote may be rejected if at least three active users believe the vote truly has no merit or was cast in bad faith. However, there must be strong reasons supporting the invalidation. "# " should be added under the last vote of each support/oppose section to show another blank line. Any proposal that has three votes or less at deadline will automatically be listed as "NO QUORUM." The original proposer then has the option to relist said proposal to generate more discussion. All proposals are archived. The original proposer must take action accordingly if the outcome of the proposal dictates it. If it requires the help of a sysop, the proposer can ask for that help. Proposals can not be made about System Operator promotions and demotions. Sysops can only be promoted and demoted by the will of Bureaucrats. There shouldn't be proposals about creating articles on a underrepresented or completely absent subject, unless there is major disagreement about whether the content should be included. To organize efforts about completing articles on missing subjects, try creating a PipeProject. No proposal can overturn the decision of a previous proposal that is less than 4 weeks (28 days) old. If a proposal has more than ten votes, it can only pass or fail by a margin of three votes. If a proposal reaches the deadline and the total number of votes for each option differ by two or less votes, the deadline will be extended for another week. All proposals that end up in a tie will be extended for another week. The times are in EDT (UTC -4:00), and are set so that the user is more likely to be online at those times (after work/school, weekend nights). If a proposal is added on Saturday night at 11:59 PM EDT, the deadline is the next Saturday night at 8:00 PM. If it is a minute later, the deadline is a day plus 15 hours (Sunday), as opposed to a day minus 4 hours. CURRENTLY: 19:52, 13 May 2024 (EDT) New Features Add a character battle Recently, I had nothing to do, so I decided to stop by in Zeldawikia and I discovered an awesome community article called the Temple of Courage.[1] In this article, two Zelda characters were put to "fight". People, including those who are not users, voted for their favorite, and the one with the most votes won (obviously :P). Naturally, I didn't lose time and created and account to vote for my favorite participant. As I already told you, I liked that, so, I was wondering if we, here in the Mariowiki, could *ehem ehem* create an article like this. I gave you the link so that you can visit it in Zeldapedia. So...........what do you think? Should we create our on Mario character battle or not? Any special questions in my talk. Proposer: Supermariofan14 (talk) Deadline: April 29, 2009, 17:00 Support Supermariofan14 (talk) I really want to have this in the wiki. Oppose Walkazo (talk) - Super Mario Wiki articles are for the cold, hard facts only; save this sort of thing for a Poll. Tucayo (talk) - Per Walkazo. Actually, there was a Character Battle in the Shroom, but it was ignored. Time Q (talk): Per Walkazo. Stooben Rooben (talk) -- Per Walkazo. JerseyMarioFreak (talk) -- Yeah per everybody Yoshario (talk) - Per Walkazo. This seems more of a forum-related thing. Comments Perhaps this idea could be incorporated into the 'Shroom? Super Mario Bros. (talk) That idea was in the 'Shroom. --Blitzwing 19:39, 25 April 2009 (EDT) Actually, Walkazo has a decent idea there. A bracket of sorts could be placed on the forums while the actual voting could be held via the Poll, kind of like the GFAQs Character Battles. Might be a fun little time waster. -- Ghost Jam (talk) Removals None at the moment. Splits & Merges None at the moment. Changes Policy on Soundtracks Looking through the Wiki, I've noticed that we have very inconsistent coverage of soundtracks. This is because we have no policy on soundtracks. Our current soundtrack coverage consists of Music and subpages, and Template:Media. As it is, these pages are maintained according to the standard of "whatever we felt like at the time." Many of them include unofficial track names and links to full tracks from the games. I believe this system is unacceptable for several reasons: In linking the soundtracks, we might inhibit Nintendo's ability to make a profit, as game soundtracks are often sold as standalone products or promotional merchandise. Most songs from games are not officially named. Therefore, they all fall under the categories of conjectural info and fanon. Relating to #1 above, their inclusion may put the wiki in a questionable legal situation. Therefore, I propose we instate one of the following alternative policies: Cropped Soundtracks: Include soundtracks, but ONLY as clips of the first, say, 30 seconds of each song. Degraded Quality: Include soundtracks at a low bitrate, so the clips will be undesirably to people looking to pirate the soundtrack. No Coverage: Do not cover game soundtracks. Proposer: Twentytwofiftyseven (talk) Deadline: 2 May, 2009, 20:00 Cropped Soundtracks Degraded Quality No Coverage Stooben Rooben (talk) - Per 2257. I find that no coverage should be made on songs featured in Mario games for all the reasons 2257 mentioned. It's an unnecessary risk that the wiki should not take. Yoshario (talk) - Per 2257. There is no reason to keep these pages, and we don't want to make Nintendo not able to make money! Tucayo (talk) - Per 2257, thats piarcy Zafum (talk) - Even though this would be destroying my pipe-project, I have to agree with 2257. Neurario (talk) - Per, See discussion. Leave as-is Discussion degraded copies make the wiki look degraded. Lu-igi board 10:08, 26 April 2009 (EDT) Lu-igi board: It's what Wikipedia does, that's really why I suggested it. Zafum: What do you plan to do about the tracks with no names, and how do you plan to solve the copyright issue? Twentytwofiftyseven (talk) I'm a little divided on the subject. I can understand the issue about MP3s on the wiki, however I'm not sure that removing the soundtrack pages altogether would be beneficial. (I'm mainly divided because I think I might be able to help contribute, meaning supply things like album covers and possibly some corrections on track details.) I'm interested to hear your thoughts on this, and thereafter I will make a decision. Neu (edits|talk|irc) 07:53, 28 April 2009 (EDT) I guess the database was reverted for some reason, (Was it Rudniki? O_o) (The database was reverted because of Rudnicki, not by him. Neu (edits|talk|irc))because I actually already talked about this. Anyway, when a soundtrack is released by Nintendo separately from a game, it would still be covered under official merchandise. Twentytwofiftyseven (talk) I see, thanks for clearing it up. Neu (edits|talk|irc) 20:09, 28 April 2009 (EDT) Make rules for Poll Selection The poll page is really falling apart, little by little. So I've come up with some rules that we could make that would eliminate unwanted, or repeated polls, and would make the page look much more formal: No signatures All polls with 2 more opposers than supporters will be deleted All repeated polls will be deleted All non mario polls will be deleted All polls that have over 10 options will be deleted Proposer: Zafum (talk) Deadline: 4 May, 2009, 17:00 Make Rules Zafum (talk) - Per me. Stooben Rooben (talk) - The polls page needs some support. I've been thinking of some new rules since the duty was just passed to me, and these look just fine. Dark boo (talk) The polls really need these rules Leave As Is Comments Miscellaneous Nothing at the moment.