MarioWiki:Appeals/Archive: Difference between revisions
m (Text replacement - "Proposals\/Archive[ _]" to "Proposals/Archive/") |
(compromising. user gets a warning instead of a lastwarn.) |
||
Line 153: | Line 153: | ||
====Keyblade Master==== | ====Keyblade Master==== | ||
Actually, it was mainly because of the templates why I issued the reminder, since I explained what conjectural templates are for prior to doing so but BigBowserBoss continued to put it on articles which had official names which is why I put a reminder there. The links really didn't have much to do with it, I just happened to leave a message regarding that in a different edit. And I wouldn't issue a warning without contacting an admin first. {{User:Keyblade Master/sig}} 07:08, March 6, 2021 (EST) | Actually, it was mainly because of the templates why I issued the reminder, since I explained what conjectural templates are for prior to doing so but BigBowserBoss continued to put it on articles which had official names which is why I put a reminder there. The links really didn't have much to do with it, I just happened to leave a message regarding that in a different edit. And I wouldn't issue a warning without contacting an admin first. {{User:Keyblade Master/sig}} 07:08, March 6, 2021 (EST) | ||
---- | |||
===Super Mario RPG=== | |||
{{AppealOutcome|lastwarn|amended|While the team agrees that Super Mario RPG has been making sweeping changes without prior discussion and was notified a couple of times, which was the primary reason for the lastwarn, some of the changes have been beneficial. The user has been overall constructive and civil dealing with the matters and has been responsive to criticism. We decided to give this user another chance, so the last warning is downgraded to a warning. {{User|Mario}} 15:31, February 9, 2024 (EST)}} | |||
[[User talk:Super Mario RPG#Last Warning]] | |||
====Super Mario RPG==== | |||
I'm requesting to appeal my final warning because it did not concern much else than me renaming the "Missions" section on Olympic Games pages to "Profiles and statistics," or adding "Tips" and "Tutorials" under that scope. Otherwise, it was vague, and even contradictory when considering the issuer liked my Missions table. Two users disagreed with the last warning, but one felt that at least minimum effort of discussion was needed before creating several of these templates I've been making. When I saw the issuer undo my edits to the Missions sections of Olympic Games events, I took the effort to manually rename all of the sections back to "Missions" and undid myself on one of the Rio 2016 arcade event pages. [[User:Super Mario RPG|Super Mario RPG]] ([[User talk:Super Mario RPG|talk]]) 13:09, February 4, 2024 (EST) | |||
====BBQ Turtle==== | |||
The warning was not given just for the "Profiles and Statistics" issue, it was due to the fact that the user has continued to make sweeping changes without much, if any, discussion or explanation first, and has been warned for doing it before. Multiple users have expressed concern about this practice, and the warning was discussed with other administration staff before being issued. [[User:BBQ Turtle|BBQ Turtle]] ([[User talk:BBQ Turtle|talk]]) 16:20, February 4, 2024 (EST) | |||
---- |
Revision as of 16:31, February 9, 2024
Ultimate Mr. LUltimate Mr. L
Wildgoosespeeder
TopmaniacTopmaniac
The RPG Gamer
TopmaniacTopmaniac
Alex95
Aside from the that, the Last Warning was given because you have been told not to add irrelevant comments to the pages, and yet, you continued to do so. So not only was the Last Warning given because of the comments, it was given due to sheer incompetence and failure to heed the advice of others. The RPG GamerThe RPG GamerI've never been reminded that using HTML wasn't allowed. Using the MediaWiki wasn't available when putting a file description for a new upload, Wildgoosespeeder then gives me a reminder for this. Last time I checked, those templates are only supposed to be for when the user doesn't stop the action after being informed about it. This was the first time I've ever been told so I personally think it's unjustified. I wasn't intentionally doing it I just didn't see the MediaWiki one available and I've not been reminded at all. Should've a reminder be issued for this? They weren't available while uploading. WildgoosespeederIt's not a {{warning}} or {{lastwarn}}. Also, you have a record of repeated warnings so this this not really a big deal in comparison. You have been here long enough to know the typical markups used. Toadette the AchieverToadette the Achiever
WildgoosespeederI saw the edit conflict dialog with the template already in place linking to my archived proposal. I just got done moving my proposal. Ran into some trouble with the link, so it was taking longer than usual to commit my edit. The edit that the user did was almost 9 hours between edits. WildgoosespeederTemplate:AppealOutcome User talk:Wildgoosespeeder#Signature WildgoosespeederI made sure that my signature wasn't in violation when I first set it up. Here's what I was able to validate for User:Wildgoosespeeder/sig:
MarioMario456[NO COMMENT] WildgoosespeederWildgoosespeeder
MarioMario456
Marshal Dan TroopMarshal Dan Troop
DKPetey99
BBQ TurtleBBQ Turtle
Owencrazyboy9
Raymond1922ARaymond1922A
User talk:Raymond1922A#Warning Baby Luigi
TheRaoul1992TheRaoul1992When I edit a page, I know what I'm doing, if I changed this, it's because the game was released. FanOfYoshiThis warning was undeserved, I respected the rules. Owencrazyboy9Owencrazyboy9
Lord Grammaticus
Toadette the Achiever
Toadette the Achiever
Bye Guy
BigBowserBossTemplate:AppealOutcome User talk:BigBowserBoss#Reminder BigBowserBossLast month, a reminder was issued to me by User:Keyblade Master, who isn't an administrator or patroller. He said I was misusing templates and links. I do agree with the templates part, but not with the links part. He and several other non-admins were removing the links I added because they looked very “awkward”. The admins said it was the right way to do it. In that way, I feel like that reminder was undeserved. Thanks - BigBowserBoss FIRE! 06:56, March 6, 2021 (EST) Keyblade MasterActually, it was mainly because of the templates why I issued the reminder, since I explained what conjectural templates are for prior to doing so but BigBowserBoss continued to put it on articles which had official names which is why I put a reminder there. The links really didn't have much to do with it, I just happened to leave a message regarding that in a different edit. And I wouldn't issue a warning without contacting an admin first. Nightwicked Bowser 07:08, March 6, 2021 (EST) Super Mario RPGTemplate:AppealOutcome User talk:Super Mario RPG#Last Warning Super Mario RPGI'm requesting to appeal my final warning because it did not concern much else than me renaming the "Missions" section on Olympic Games pages to "Profiles and statistics," or adding "Tips" and "Tutorials" under that scope. Otherwise, it was vague, and even contradictory when considering the issuer liked my Missions table. Two users disagreed with the last warning, but one felt that at least minimum effort of discussion was needed before creating several of these templates I've been making. When I saw the issuer undo my edits to the Missions sections of Olympic Games events, I took the effort to manually rename all of the sections back to "Missions" and undid myself on one of the Rio 2016 arcade event pages. Super Mario RPG (talk) 13:09, February 4, 2024 (EST) BBQ TurtleThe warning was not given just for the "Profiles and Statistics" issue, it was due to the fact that the user has continued to make sweeping changes without much, if any, discussion or explanation first, and has been warned for doing it before. Multiple users have expressed concern about this practice, and the warning was discussed with other administration staff before being issued. BBQ Turtle (talk) 16:20, February 4, 2024 (EST) |