198
edits
Talk:Koopalings: Difference between revisions
m
→Not Bowser's children
| Line 223: | Line 223: | ||
:Except that they were never his children in Japan, right? Wasn't this simply a translation issue, just like Peach being called Toadstool? As far as I know the American canon had them as children until Super Mario Advance 2 was released, then they were simply referred to as his "generals" or minions from then on. They were siblings, and of the same species as Bowser, but not necessarily Bowser's children. Miyamoto isn't really retconning anything, he's simply fixing an inconsistency between the two canons that has technically not actually been mentioned ever since they started reappearing. In Japan, they were never thought of as his children, which is presumably why they were forgotten for so long and why Bowser Jr. exists. [[User:Fizzle|Fizzle]] ([[User talk:Fizzle|talk]]) 10:15, 15 September 2012 (EDT) | :Except that they were never his children in Japan, right? Wasn't this simply a translation issue, just like Peach being called Toadstool? As far as I know the American canon had them as children until Super Mario Advance 2 was released, then they were simply referred to as his "generals" or minions from then on. They were siblings, and of the same species as Bowser, but not necessarily Bowser's children. Miyamoto isn't really retconning anything, he's simply fixing an inconsistency between the two canons that has technically not actually been mentioned ever since they started reappearing. In Japan, they were never thought of as his children, which is presumably why they were forgotten for so long and why Bowser Jr. exists. [[User:Fizzle|Fizzle]] ([[User talk:Fizzle|talk]]) 10:15, 15 September 2012 (EDT) | ||
:::<s>He said they aren't his children. That means that THEY ARE NOT HIS CHILDREN. That is what Miyamoto himself said. They aren't related to Bowser at all. Those who disagree just can't face the truth.<s> *Just forget what I just said there. I was just angry. What I'm trying to hay across is that there is even proof that they are not Bowser's kids. For example, Bowser never shows fatherly love to the Koopalings like he does with Jr. I say they aren't his kids and any pages saying that they are should be changed as such. However, I am aware that some people disagree with me. I suggest we make a proposal on this. [[User:Mario3D64|Mario3D64]] ([[User talk:Mario3D64|talk]]) 10:59, 15 September 2012 (EDT) | :::<s>He said they aren't his children. That means that THEY ARE NOT HIS CHILDREN. That is what Miyamoto himself said. They aren't related to Bowser at all. Those who disagree just can't face the truth.<s> | ||
*Just forget what I just said there. I was just angry. What I'm trying to hay across is that there is even proof that they are not Bowser's kids. For example, Bowser never shows fatherly love to the Koopalings like he does with Jr. I say they aren't his kids and any pages saying that they are should be changed as such. However, I am aware that some people disagree with me. I suggest we make a proposal on this. [[User:Mario3D64|Mario3D64]] ([[User talk:Mario3D64|talk]]) 10:59, 15 September 2012 (EDT) | |||