Talk:Noki elder: Difference between revisions
Time Turner (talk | contribs) (the guide makes the noki/niko mistake multiple times) |
Ninja Squid (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
Line 24: | Line 24: | ||
That's every mention of the guy that I could find. As for the Prima guide, Blocky has told me that he couldn't find any meaningful names, which I assume means that he's had similar results to myself. "Old Noki" might be a viable option, if only for its consistency in the NP guide, though it's not a particularly satisfactory answer. {{User:Time Turner/sig}} | That's every mention of the guy that I could find. As for the Prima guide, Blocky has told me that he couldn't find any meaningful names, which I assume means that he's had similar results to myself. "Old Noki" might be a viable option, if only for its consistency in the NP guide, though it's not a particularly satisfactory answer. {{User:Time Turner/sig}} | ||
:So, we have two choices, keep that name or we change it for "Old Noki", which is the most used name in the guides. But the lowercase "o" make it a similar case to "twin Dragoneels" they didn't got a different name from the parent species. This Noki didn't got a different name for the species. Do [[Noki Elder's Grandson]] is mentioned somewhere and give a clues for Noki Elder's name?--{{User:LudwigVon/sig}} 20:58, 6 June 2016 (EDT) |
Revision as of 20:58, June 6, 2016
Name
This talk page or section has a conflict or a question that needs to be answered. Please try to help and resolve the issue by leaving a comment. |
Noki Elder is conjectural apparently, but the others names (Old Fisher Man and Noki Fisherman), are they mentioned in the game or a guide? Because, if those two names appear somewhere I propose we name change the name for Noki Fisherman since this would be the best descriptive in my opinion rather than a conjectural name. This will also affect Noki Elder's grandson if he don't have a name.--(TALK) 14:37, 6 June 2016 (EDT)
- I can personally confirm that the official Nintendo Power and BradyGames guides don't give specific names to the old coot. Nintedo Power refers to him with a consistently generic term:
- "Go to point A [on the map in the guide] and speak with the old Noki"
- "The old Noki will give you a special helmet and place you in a bottle"
- "Jump up to the ledge [...] and speak to the old Noki"
- "As soon as you appear in Episode 6 you'll meet the old Noki"
- "Talk to the old Noki on the top of the cliff"
- BradyGames offers even less consistency, though more variety:
- "After talking to the old Noki fisherman at the beginning of the Episode"
- "The old Noki man admits his theory of the toxic lake was wrong"
- "look high above the old man's head"
- "the old fisherman greets him with a bottle by his side"
- "The old Noki man is located on the ledge where Mario fought Chorobe[sic]"
- "The old Noki man has finally gotten to the bottom of the toxic water mystery"
- "From the old man's ledge"
- "the old Niko[sic] man was finally correct"
- "The old man says there's a friend yours up on the mountain"
- "After talking to the old Noki man"
- "to the left of the ledge where the old man stood"
- "The old man would be so disappointed"
- "As you begin on the platform with the old Noki man"
That's every mention of the guy that I could find. As for the Prima guide, Blocky has told me that he couldn't find any meaningful names, which I assume means that he's had similar results to myself. "Old Noki" might be a viable option, if only for its consistency in the NP guide, though it's not a particularly satisfactory answer. Hello, I'm Time Turner.
- So, we have two choices, keep that name or we change it for "Old Noki", which is the most used name in the guides. But the lowercase "o" make it a similar case to "twin Dragoneels" they didn't got a different name from the parent species. This Noki didn't got a different name for the species. Do Noki Elder's Grandson is mentioned somewhere and give a clues for Noki Elder's name?--(TALK) 20:58, 6 June 2016 (EDT)