MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive/41: Difference between revisions

MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive/41 (view source)

Revision as of 03:01, January 30, 2015

5,745 bytes added , 9 years ago

m

Archiving

Yoshi876

Autopatrolled users, 'Shroom writers

23,679

edits

@@ Line 619: / Line 619: @@
 :::::I just saw the page, and it definitely should be replaced by sections in articles. That page should be removed, it is unorganized and has little information.  {{User:57sugoi/sig}} 19:25, 2 January 2015 (EST)
+----
+===Crteate an arcade page ===
+<span style="color:red;font-family:Comic Sans MS;font-size:150%">DON'T CREATE 2-5</span>
+(UPDATE)
+Ok, what 1337star said dawned on me as an even better idea. Again as I said in the comments I wrote this at 3 Am and I was so tired I wrote my first idea down without any 2nd thoughts. I don’t know if it’s too late to change but I still am going to change the proposal below to the creation of separate articles on the various different arcade machines that Mario games have been on.
+A little while ago I wanted to search for all the Mario arcade games, I typed in the toolbar arcade games and all that showed up was a little category list thing naming the names of the arcade games. Its wired that the wiki with full articles about every platform a Mario game came out on only has a small list for the platform Mario got his start on. The page would be the same as any console or platform a small summary about the platform and how it was involved with the Mario franchise and a list of all Mario and Donkey Kong games. So if the Philips cd-i can gets its own page than arcade games should to.
+'''Proposer''': {{User|Green6017 Guy}}<br>
+'''Deadline''': January 28, 2015, 23:59 GMT
+====Support====
+#{{User|Green6017 Guy}} Per me as this is my proposal.
+#{{User|Toadbrigade5}} I'm with you on this, and per you. But however, I must point out we don't know much about the arcade games, they simply aren't around anymore. Its likely they aren't here cause no one can find anything on it. I'd like the info, but its going to be really hard to get.
+====Oppose====
+#{{User|1337star}} I don't agree with the proposal as written. As Mario notes in the comments, "arcade" is not a platform, it's a group of platforms. It would be like us making an article on "video game console" (rather than [[Nintendo Entertainment System]] or [[Wii]]) or "personal computer" (rather than [[MS-DOS]] or Apple II). Now I would support articles on the various different arcade machines that Mario games have been on (in fact, we already have one: [[Nintendo PlayChoice-10]]), so long as it follows the guidelines of [[MarioWiki:New Articles Policy#Consoles|MW:NAP]].
+#{{User|Madz the Penguin}} Per 1337star. Calling something "arcade games" is very vague and unprofessional, and I would rather mention the actual system it's on. Since we don't exactly know the specific name for it, we can't make an article for it, and we must find other ways to mention the system.
+#{{User|Ghost Jam}} Generally, per standard procedure, specifically standard proposal rule 15. Broadly, now that we have some opinions rolling, per 1337star. I see where you're going with this, but it needs to be narrowed down a bit. Generally speaking, "arcade" isn't considered a "system" in the traditional sense, so care needs to be taken in how it's logged in the database. Not against the whole idea, but it requires more discussion than your libel to get in a proposal.
+#{{User|Stonehill}} Per 1337star.
+#{{User|Andymii}} Per 1337star.
+====Comments====
+The proposal is kind of vague when it comes to arcade. Are you talking arcade as a whole or make pages for separate arcade consoles? If the former, then there's the question of consistency: why doesn't handheld get its own page either? If the latter, we might get several articles on arcade consoles, but I'm not sure if that's a good way to do things. For instance, ''[[Mario Kart Arcade GP 2]]'' uses the Triforce arcade console. P.S. It's also really difficult to read your proposal; do you need help with grammar and spelling? {{User:Mario/sig}} 01:42, 21 January 2015 (EST)
+Sorry I wrote it while I was half asleep at 3 Am in the morning. I was planing on writing it earlier but stuff happend. sorry again and if I have the time Ill rewrite it.
+[[File:Unknown Shy Guy.PNG|30px]] [[User:Green6017 Guy|<span style="font-fancy:serif;color:#0F3">Green6017 Guy</span>]][[File:Unknown Shy Guy.PNG|30px]]
+Just a note here on some of the different arcade boards that already have/could have articles:
+*'''[[Nintendo Vs. System]]''' - system used by ''[[Vs. Super Mario Bros.]]'', ''[[Dr. Mario (game)#Vs. Dr. Mario|Vs. Dr. Mario]]'', and, well, any of the ''Mario'' arcade games with "Vs." in the title.
+*'''[[Nintendo PlayChoice-10]]''' - system used by the arcade ports of certain NES games: ''[[Super Mario Bros.]]'', ''[[NES Open Tournament Golf]]'', etc.
+*'''Nintendo Super System''' - system used by the arcade ports of certain SNES games. The only Mario game on it was ''[[Super Mario World]]''.
+*'''Super Famicom Box''' - system used by the arcade ports of certain other SNES games: ''[[Super Mario Kart]]'', ''[[Super Mario All-Stars]]'', and ''[[Donkey Kong Country]]''.
+*'''Triforce''' - system used by ''[[Mario Kart Arcade GP]]''/''[[Mario Kart Arcade GP 2|2]]'', ''[[Donkey Kong: Jungle Fever]]'', and ''[[Donkey Kong: Banana Kingdom]]''.
+These are just the ones I could find from a quick search on Wikipedia (plus other sources when Wikipedia was vague. If you're serious about improving our arcade coverage, doing further research on these five and finding others would be a good start. -- [[User:1337star|1337star]] <sup>([[User talk:1337star|Mailbox SP]])</sup> 15:35, 23 January 2015 (EST)
+This proposal is somewhat of a mixed idea in my opinion.  We should have another option for giving each individual Arcade platform its own article and that is the option I would support and I'd imagine many other people who are currently opposing this proposal would switch their votes to that option too.  Individual users are not allowed to edit other users proposals so we'd need Green6017 Guy to rewrite it to continue.  {{User:Kart Player 2011/sig}} 17:25, 23 January 2015 (EST)
 ----