Talk:The Cannoli Clan: Difference between revisions
(→Merge with List of Implied Organizations: a bit late in the game to vote, but oh well) |
|||
| Line 20: | Line 20: | ||
#{{User|Commander Code-8}} Per proposer | #{{User|Commander Code-8}} Per proposer | ||
#{{User|Loxo}} Per proposer | #{{User|Loxo}} Per proposer | ||
#{{User|Lost Mini Star09}} Per proposer. | #{{User|Lost Mini Star09}} Per proposer. | ||
===Merge with List of Implied Organizations=== | ===Merge with List of Implied Organizations=== | ||
#{{User|Walkazo}} - The clan has more in common with organizations like "Lakitu Air" and the "Yoshi Fanclub" than it does with any of the implied character entries. Like those two organizations, a member of the clan ''does'' appear, but the overall group is only mentioned, and unlike something like Rosalina's family, there aren't actually any ''specific characters'' mentioned. A clan is not a character, and merging it in with the organizations would be more logical and consistent than any of the other options. | #{{User|Walkazo}} - The clan has more in common with organizations like "Lakitu Air" and the "Yoshi Fanclub" than it does with any of the implied character entries. Like those two organizations, a member of the clan ''does'' appear, but the overall group is only mentioned, and unlike something like Rosalina's family, there aren't actually any ''specific characters'' mentioned. A clan is not a character, and merging it in with the organizations would be more logical and consistent than any of the other options. | ||
#{{User|Vommack}} This argument makes more sense, when I take a look at it. | |||
===Leave as is=== | ===Leave as is=== | ||
Revision as of 21:07, June 15, 2012
When you say "Count Cannoli" doesn't that imply that Canolli is his last name? That would mean that this page should be moved to "Canolli Family". Opinions plzkthxbai. ~Uniju(T-C-E)
Move to List of Implied Characters
As stated by the header, we should move this to the List of Implied Characters, since none of the Clan save the latest member, Count Cannoli, makes an appearance. Any objections? Redstar 07:47, 27 December 2009 (EST)
Merge this page with List of Implied Characters or List of Implied Organizations
|
This talk page section contains an unresolved talk page proposal. Please try to help and resolve the issue by voting or leaving a comment. |
Current time: Saturday, June 1, 2024, 10:24 GMT
Just like Rosalina's Family, this article is about an implied family which has only one member actually seen. Unlike Rosalina's Family, this page is not merged into an Implied article. There are three options:
- Merge the article into List of Implied Characters
- Merge the article into List of Implied Organizations
- Keep it separate
I propose that we merge this article into an implied list, because only one member is seen, and we have merged all of the other implied articles into lists.
Proposer: Humbug (talk)
Deadline June 17, 2012, 23:59 GMT
Merge with List of Implied Characters
- Humbug (talk) Because the aforementioned Rosalina's Family is merged into this article, I think it is the best option.
- Commander Code-8 (talk) Per proposer
- Loxo (talk) Per proposer
- Lost Mini Star09 (talk) Per proposer.
Merge with List of Implied Organizations
- Walkazo (talk) - The clan has more in common with organizations like "Lakitu Air" and the "Yoshi Fanclub" than it does with any of the implied character entries. Like those two organizations, a member of the clan does appear, but the overall group is only mentioned, and unlike something like Rosalina's family, there aren't actually any specific characters mentioned. A clan is not a character, and merging it in with the organizations would be more logical and consistent than any of the other options.
- Vommack (talk) This argument makes more sense, when I take a look at it.
Leave as is
- Raven Effect (talk) Technically the The Cannoli Clan does appear in the game since Count Cannoli appears in the game and is a member of the clan. And Rosalina's family refers to her mother, father, and sister but not Rosalina herself so there is a difference between the two in that respect.
Comments
@RavenEffect: Thinking of it that way, Rosalina's family appears in-game because Rosalina herself appears.Vommack (talk)
- But it doesn't refer to her when it's talking about the family it refers to her mom, dad, and sister I believe. Raven Effect (talk)
