Editing Talk:Elevator Key
From the Super Mario Wiki, the Mario encyclopedia
Jump to navigationJump to search
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision | Your text | ||
Line 27: | Line 27: | ||
== Split the Elevator Keys == | == Split the Elevator Keys == | ||
{{ | {{TPP}} | ||
These are so obviously different items that I don't think I need to detail exactly how they're different. Yes, they have the same name - should we also merge the [[Harry (Mario Tennis series)|tennis player]] and the [[Harry (Mario Golf)|golfer]] for having the same name? If you want to make the case that the keys aren't notable enough to deserve individual articles, [[:Category:Keys|there's an entire category]] that disagrees with you. If you want to make the point that these keys shouldn't have articles in the first place, this is not the place to do so (and take note that [[MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_16#Merge_Keys_Articles|this has been attempted]] at least once before). Right now, let's make things consistent with the rest of the wiki and give these individual articles. One final point: You do not get rid of stubs by lumping a bunch of articles together. It's like trying to get rid of dust by sweeping it under a carpet; you've done nothing to actually alleviate the problem, you've only made it look like everything's fine. | These are so obviously different items that I don't think I need to detail exactly how they're different. Yes, they have the same name - should we also merge the [[Harry (Mario Tennis series)|tennis player]] and the [[Harry (Mario Golf)|golfer]] for having the same name? If you want to make the case that the keys aren't notable enough to deserve individual articles, [[:Category:Keys|there's an entire category]] that disagrees with you. If you want to make the point that these keys shouldn't have articles in the first place, this is not the place to do so (and take note that [[MarioWiki:Proposals/Archive_16#Merge_Keys_Articles|this has been attempted]] at least once before). Right now, let's make things consistent with the rest of the wiki and give these individual articles. One final point: You do not get rid of stubs by lumping a bunch of articles together. It's like trying to get rid of dust by sweeping it under a carpet; you've done nothing to actually alleviate the problem, you've only made it look like everything's fine. |